Mirrored: 2nd of November 2011, 19:00 Original: www.tor.com Views: 60 Settings: Loading the mirror...
Ad Banner _____________________ [ Search ] tor.com | Tor.com Science Fiction. Fantasy. The Universe. * Stories & Comics * Series * Gallery * Community * Forum * Rss register log in Log In Using Facebook Twitter Google -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Your tor.com Acct _____________________ _____________________ [ login ] [ ] remember me forgot password Mon Aug 9 2010 2:56pm reddit this! SU: Submit Add to goodreads f: share retweet +1 email bookmark 6 comments Aliens, Steppe Nomads, and just the right amount of romance: Kate Elliott's Jaran Jo Walton Jaran is one of my comfort books, reading it always makes me feel happy. I've enjoyed a lot of Kate Elliott's books, but this is the one I keep coming back to. I didn't pick it up now because I was feeling in need of comforting but because she mentioned some of the characters in a Livejournal post and it made me miss them. I don't know if other people feel homesick for certain books, but I quite often do. Jaran is a science fiction romance, and whether or not I'll like a romance generally depends on what else is going on and how interesting that is. Here we have everything done just right. Tess is on the rebound, and she's rebounding from Earth to one of the planets her brother owns as part of an alien Empire, primitive interdicted Rhui. When she gets there, she finds she's thousands of miles from where she expected to be, witness to illicit alien trafficking. She follows the aliens to find out what's going on and encounters a fascinating and complex culture of steppe nomads. So there's a set of interlocking adventure stories at all levels here, not to mention culture clashes and ever-widening implications. Tess's brother is trying to rebel against the aliens, the aliens are doing something very mysterious on Rhui, the Jaran, the nomads, are getting ready to unite and drive back the settled people. This is a story about worlds changing, lots of worlds, and within that, it's a story of people overcoming strangeness and distrust and cultural expectations to fall in love. Jaran stands alone, it is a complete story. There are also two trilogies set in this universe, the Highroad trilogy (written under the name Alis Rasmussen) and the Sword of Heaven trilogy. The Highroad books are prequels, set in the wider universe of humans and Chapalii and settled planets, the Sword of Heaven books are direct sequels to Jaran, continuing the story, expanding it, and repeating themes. I seldom feel any need to re-read any of them-only if I really can't bear to leave the characters and the world at the end of Jaran. Jaran stands alone so well that while Elliott's natural length may be the seven book series, I find it enough. But because the other books exist, Jaran is richer-the Chapalii are fascinating aliens, the wide universe in the hints and glimpses we get is detailed and more complex than it would otherwise be. I'd read more Jaran books if there were any-but in the same way I'm pretty much going to read anything Elliott writes. Jaran is a small scale story set in a larger scale one. The larger scale one serves to give depth and context and significance to the smaller one. They're also good stories. On the personal level, Jaran is about how Tess becomes confident and finds herself. That's why it works so well as a love story, and that's why the volume is complete in itself-Tess has discovered what the Chapalii were doing, even if that opens out a wider mystery, and reported back, and she has reached the end of her emotional arc. The Jaran material culture is clearly based on the Mongols, with their tents and horses and customs. The system in which men and women have different responsibilities and spheres but are both important is done very well-and the fact that Tess (for most of the book) gets away with the privileges of both genders without really the responsibilities of either is dealt with at the end. It feels like a real culture in the small and large things. I very much like the way that during the course of the novel Tess has lovers that do not consume her like tinder before she ends up with the one who inevitably does. Lovers are a woman's choice, and marriage is a man's choice-and we see characters who exemplify all the problems you'd expect to find with that. There's a lot of very interesting and nuanced thinking about gender and relationships and family here. As well as love, adventure, and spaceships, the book encompasses a great journey across a continent. Travel is something that's very difficult to write without making it repetitive or dull, and Elliott does very well here with writing about the routine and the surprising elements of the journey. This is a notable example of how to do something difficult correctly. I don't know enough about horses to know if she also got them right-but anyway, they're modified horses. Genetically modified by aliens, in this particular case. This is not a big-idea book. It's an absorbing book with great characters that has had a lot of thought put into the universe and which gets the details right. There should be more SF like this. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Jo Walton is a science fiction and fantasy writer. She's published eight novels, most recently Half a Crown and Lifelode, and two poetry collections. She reads a lot, and blogs about it here regularly. She comes from Wales but lives in Montreal where the food and books are more varied. books | Written Word | reading | reread | science fiction | sf | romance | Kate Elliott | Jaran 6 comments Claire de Trafford 1. ClairedeT VIEW ALL BY | Monday August 09, 2010 05:03pm EDT I also love Kate Elliott and am very grateful for her 7 book length style but like you have never felt the urge (well, every so often I look on Amazon for second hand copies) to read the others in this universe - didn't know about the Alis ones, will look up now, thanks Jo :) As you say, Jaran is such a lovely stand-alone. The love story is wonderful but not intrusive if that isn't your bag. Horses! Aliens! Romance! What's not to love? Holly Bird 2. HollyBird VIEW ALL BY | Monday August 09, 2010 07:58pm EDT Thanks, Jo! Recent character discussions by Kate Elliott on her LJ reminded me as well that I was due for a re-reading of Jaran. (Hmmm. And you just reminded me I need to replace my long-lost paperback. There. Just ordered another. It's *that* good.) Jaran's definitely a book to go back to and live in for a while. By the way, Tor's free download of Spirit Gate a while back introduced me to Elliott's latest and I couldn't wait to buy the next two in the Crossroads Trilogy. Like Jaran: memorable characters and terrific world-building. Peter Stone 3. Peter1742 VIEW ALL BY | Monday August 09, 2010 10:13pm EDT | amended on Monday August 09, 2010 10:14pm EDT It's been ages since I read the Highroad trilogy, but my distinct impression was that Jaran was a prequel to the Highroad trilogy, and not the other way around. Either way, the Highroad books are set a long way in time and space from the Jaran books. Either way, they're all worth reading. Jo Walton 4. bluejo VIEW ALL BY | Tuesday August 10, 2010 08:05am EDT Peter 1742 -- it's a long time since I read them as well, and you may be right. Peter Stone 5. Peter1742 VIEW ALL BY | Tuesday August 10, 2010 10:51am EDT Very minor spoilers for the Highroad trilogy, as well as for the end of the probably-never-to-be-finished 8 book Jaran series: scroll over to view. In the last book of the Highroad trilogy, you learn about a successful rebellion against a galactic empire ... presumably the rebellion that Tess's brother is leading. Jaquandor 6. Jaquandor Tuesday August 10, 2010 10:32pm EDT Wow -- I just posted about Jaran myself. I loved the book, for many, if not all, of the same reasons you give. It's just a wonderful book! There's not a single human motivation in the book that doesn't make sense or that feels contrived for plot reasons. Subscribe to this thread Receive notification by email when a new comment is added. You must be a registered user to subscribe to threads. [ Register ] [ Log in ] [ Cancel ] Post a comment Name _____________________ Email _____________________ (bbCode allowed): ____________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________ [ preview ] are you getting the tor.com newsletter? follow tor.com twitter facebook Looking for Tor Books? go to tor-forge.com Latest Posts Ryan Britt and Emily Asher-Perrin Gary Mitchell Strikes Back: IDW's Star Trek #2 28 seconds ago Jo Walton Rescuing Children in Wartime: Nevil Shute's Pied Piper 1 hour ago Amanda Rutter and Bill Capossere Malazan Re-read of the Fallen: Midnight Tides, Prologue 1 hour ago Tim Maughan Why You Can't Miss Redline: An Interview with Director Takeshi Koike 3 hours ago Stubby the Rocket Final Parody Trailer for The Muppets Gets Meta 3 hours ago > show all Latest Comments djk1978 on The Malazan Re-read of the Fallen: Gardens of the Moon, Chapter 24 and Epilogue 1 minute ago ZetaStriker on Malazan Re-read of the Fallen: Midnight Tides, Prologue 2 minutes ago a1ay on The future of the Commonwealth: Nevil Shute's In the Wet 4 minutes ago HArai on The Malazan Re-read of the Fallen: Gardens of the Moon, Chapter 24 and Epilogue 6 minutes ago anthonypero on The Wheel of Time Re-read: The Gathering Storm, Part 7 10 minutes ago rogerothornhill on Morning Roundup: Gaiman Reads Thurber. Stewart is Spongebob. Tennant and Tate Refuse to Stop Singing. 11 minutes ago Treesinger on The Malazan Re-read of the Fallen: Gardens of the Moon, Chapter 24 and Epilogue 17 minutes ago > show all Hot Bookmarks NaNoWriMo Success Stories by Natalie Zutter "Man's more like to change than die": C.J. Cherryh's Forty Thousand in Gehenna by Jo Walton Sleeping under the wagon: More spoilers for Patrick Rothfuss's The Wise Man's Fear by Jo Walton Progress or Change? Cory Doctorow's The Great Big Beautiful Tomorrow by Stefan Raets The Wheel of Time Re-read: The Path of Daggers, Part 15 by Leigh Butler Once Upon a Time vs. Grimm: Battle of the Pilots by Teresa Jusino The Wheel of Time Re-read: The Path of Daggers, Part 11 by Leigh Butler 2011 Halloween Board Game Roundup by Bob Gallo DaedylusSL on All Hallow's Read Sweepstakes: Frankenstein The Wheel of Time Reread by Leigh Butler Of Interest Scalzi talks about cheaply made, but very lucrative science fiction films -RB The Anglophenia blog has all six Bonds duking it out in a grudge match -RB Nicola Scott to pencil Superman #3 -RB This Corgi is dressed like Serenity -RB Ready for the Quidditch World Cup? -RB David Tennant, Catherine Tate and John Barrowman say farewell to Russell T. Davies and Julie Gardner through a good old fashioned musical number. -EA Neil Gaiman reads a new animated version of James Thurber's The Thirteen Clocks -CL Contest just launched where you can have a cameo in a Star Trek comic book as a redshirt! -RB Dick estate sues MRC over Adjustment Bureau righs issues -RB Eddie Murphy is working on a science fiction movie. Oh no! -RB A pregnant woman dresses as the Death Star for Halloween -RB J.K. Rowling reveals she toyed with killing off Ronny the Bear! -RB How to Be a Retronaut has a beautiful post on how a Kindle would be explained to Charles Dickens -RB John Scalzi has posted some GREAT writing prompts over on the AMC's filmcritic.com. Totally, brilliantly, fun. -RB An inside look at The Hobbit filming from Ain't it Cool -RB > show all tor.com Bloggers Ryan Britt Emily Asher-Perrin Jo Walton Bill Capossere Amanda Rutter Tim Maughan Stubby the Rocket Liz Bourke Allegra Frazier Stefan Raets Natalie Zutter > show all About FAQ | About Us | Contact Us | Submissions Moderation Policy | Terms of Use | Privacy Notice Blog Archive 2011 January | February | March | April | May | June | July | August | September | October | November | 2010 January | February | March | April | May | June | July | August | September | October | November | December | 2009 January | February | March | April | May | June | July | August | September | October | November | December | 2008 July | August | September | October | November | December | Tags steampunk, Culture, fantasy, books, Social issues, Science, sf, Written Word, animation, Comics, Tv, Art & illustration, short fiction, Star Trek, literary criticism, Interviews, Fantasy, science fiction, Internet, Robert Jordan, reading, Events, urban fantasy, ...and Related Subjects, illustration, art, reread, reviews, television, Movies >> see all Search tor.com _____________________ advanced search [ Search ] (c) 2011 Macmillan | All stories, art, and posts are the copyright of their respective authors DCSIMG Quantcast