Mirrored: 7th of September 2011, 08:53 Original: www.raagvamdatt.com Views: 125 Settings: Loading the mirror...
Link: image_src Link: index: Financial Planning Demystified Link: start: United we stand - Mutual Funds (MFs) Link: prev: Income Tax (IT) treatment of House Rent Allowance (HRA) Link: next: Auto Sweep Facility: Smart way to make your money work harder Link: shortlink Link: canonical Link: canonical * Income Tax * Non Resident Indians * Insurance * Financial Planning & Investment * Loans * Mutual Funds * News * Other * Real Estate * Shares / Equities Financial Planning Demystified www.RaagVamdatt.com [IMG] * Financial Planning Service * [IMG]An online financial planning service that aims to look after your long term financial well being. Includes life & health insurance analysis, asset allocation analysis net worth calculation and planning for your financial goals like retirement, kids' education, kids' marriage, etc. It includes specific investment advice - where to invest how much every month to achieve your goals. Click here for more details. * MF Portfolio Analysis * [IMG]Analysis of your current Mutual Fund (MF) portfolio: Get accurate buy / hold / sell recommendation for the MF schemes you hold, get names of MF schemes you should be investing in if the recommendation for any of your schemes is "sell" & get your MF portfolio judged for concentration risk. Click here fore more details. * ULIP Evaluation & Review * [IMG]Do you currently have a ULIP, and are wondering whether to continue it or not? Did an insurance agent sell you a ULIP based on some promises, and now you are reconsidering you decision? Here is a service that would analyze the ULIP policy you have, and tell you whether you should continue with it or not. Click here for more details. * E-Books * [IMG]Downloadable e-books on various topics in personal finance. Why an e-book? It is easy to store, easy to read (PDF format), contains links to relevant resources on the internet and has interlinking between sections for easy navigation between related topics. Most of all, e-books are downloadable - you can buy it online and start reading it in less than 2 minutes! Equity Investment is Risk Free - Here's the Proof October 6, 2008 by Raag Vamdatt . 12 Comments Check out the comprehensive Financial Planning Service by Raag Vamdatt, or check out all products & services. IFrame Tweet You must have heard many times that investment in stocks is risky. Not always. In fact, it can be totally risk-free if you follow a simple rule. Read on... "No risk, no returns." This sounds familiar, doesn't it? Haven't you heard this, and similar things, repeated over and over again? Everyone agrees that equities give the best return, but only because they are risky. But that is not always the case. The riskiness of stocks depends on how long you keep invested. If you invest for the long term, equities are virtually risk-free. This is a very bold statement to make. So, let's analyze past 18 year's data, and see how risky stock investment actually is. (The idea presented here is radical - and therefore, the article is longer! So, please bear with me. If you have any questions, please feel free to ask them in the comments section at the bottom of the page) The Data +----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | | 1 Year | 5 Years | 10 Years | 15 Years | |---------------------------------------+----------------+---------------+----------------+----------------| | Maximum Return | 242.24% | 43.88% | 18.98% | 16.04% | |---------------------------------------+----------------+---------------+----------------+----------------| | Minimum Return | -47.37% | -5.33% | -1.13% | -7.23% | |---------------------------------------+----------------+---------------+----------------+----------------| | No. of Periods | 208 | 160 | 100 | 40 | |---------------------------------------+----------------+---------------+----------------+----------------| | No. of Times Negative Return | 75 | 24 | 1 | 0 | |---------------------------------------+----------------+---------------+----------------+----------------| | Percentage of Negative Returns | 36% | 15% | 1% | 0% | +----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ (Download this spreadsheet that contains the full data and analysis. You need to be logged-in to download the spreadsheet. Please take advantage of the free registration that takes less than a minute. To know the benefits of registration, please click here.) What Has Been Done? The values presented are for the Nifty index, for which the data is available starting June 1990. In this analysis, Nifty is being used as a proxy for stocks in general. Now the story. Say we have 4 people: Mr. Short Term: Mr. Short Term invests in the Nifty on the first trading day of every month, holds it for a year, and sells it exactly after 1 year. Thus, a purchase made in June 1990 is sold in June 1991. Mr. Short Term does this every month, month after month. Starting in June 1990, he has done this 208 times. He last sold his Nifty in Oct 2008, which was bought in Oct 2007. How has he fared till now? The maximum profit he has ever made is 242% per year. That's whopping! But at the same time, the maximum loss he has ever made is -47% per year - and that is equally whopping! Starting June 1990, he has made 208 1-year investments, every month. Out of these 208 investments that he has made, 75 times he made a loss. That is, he made a loss 36% of times. Mr. Medium Term: Mr. Medium Term also invests in the Nifty on the first trading day of every month. But he holds it for 5 years, and sells it exactly after 5 years. Thus, a purchase made in June 1990 is sold in June 1995. Like Mr. Short Term, Mr. Medium Term does this every month, month after month. Starting in June 1990, he has done this 160 times. He last sold his Nifty in Oct 2008, which was bought in Oct 2003. The maximum profit he has ever made is 44% per year. Quite good! But at the same time, the maximum loss he has ever made is -5% - again not insignificant! Out of the 160 investments that he has made, he made a loss 24 times. That is, he made a loss 15% of times. Ms. Long Term: Ms. Long Term invests in the Nifty on the first trading day of every month, holds it for 10 years, and sells it exactly after 10 years. Thus, a purchase made in June 1990 is sold in June 2000. Ms. Long Term does this every month. Starting in June 1990, she has done this 100 times. She last sold her Nifty in Oct 2008, which was bought in Oct 1998. How has she fared till now? The maximum profit she has ever made is 19% per year. That's very good. And the maximum loss she has ever made is -1% per year - barely a loss. Out of the 100 investments that she has made, she has made a loss only once. That is, she made a loss 1% of times. Ms. Very Long Term: Ms. Very Long Term also invests in the Nifty on the first trading day of every month, but holds it for 15 years, and sells it after exactly 15 year. Thus, a purchase made in June 1990 is sold in June 2005. Ms. Very Long Term does this every month, month after month. Starting in June 1990, she has done this 40 times. She last sold her Nifty in Oct 2008, which was bought in Oct 1993. And how has she fared till now? The maximum profit she has ever made is 16% per year. And how much is her maximum loss? Guess what - she has never made a loss! That's just WOW! So, for the 40 investments that she has made, she has made no loss. That is, she made a loss 0% of times. (Download this spreadsheet that contains the full data and analysis. You need to be logged-in to download the spreadsheet. Please take advantage of the free registration that takes less than a minute. To know the benefits of registration, please click here.) Analysis - What Does This Mean? There are many interesting patterns in this data - did you notice any? Variation: As the time span of investment increases, the Variation (or what is statistically called Standard Deviation) in returns decreases. For 1 year, returns range from +242% to -47%, whereas for 5, 10 and 15 years, the ranges are +44% to -5%, +19% to -1% and +16% to +7% respectively. Predictability: This gets derived from the above point - As the holding period increases, the variation decreases, and therefore, the outcome is much more predictable. So, although for one year investments you can't be sure of the outcome at all, for 10 & 15 years investments, you can be fairly certain about the kind of return that you would get. Maximum Return: For investments of 1 year, the return of 242% sounds exotic! But remember, it is highly unpredictable, and it is only for 1 year. Compared to this, the returns from 10 & 15 year investments sound pale at 19% and 16% respectively. But let's note that these are the returns over 10 year and 15 year periods - the return is CAGR. You get this return for each of these years. Consider the effect of compounding, and you would understand that this has a potential to explode your initial investment! To give you an idea, Rs. 1000 would become Rs. 5695 in 10 years at 19% - that is, would become 5.7 times in 10 years. Or, Rs. 1000 would become Rs. 9265.2 in 15 years at 16% - that is, would become 9.3 times in 15 years. This is fabulous, and can't be matched by most other investment classes. (To know more about CAGR - Compound Annual Growth Rate - please read "Compound Annual Growth Rate". To know more about compounding and its effects, please read "Start saving early and gain from Compounding - Early bird gets the worm") Minimum Return: The maximum possible returns are fabulous for long term or very long term investments. What about the minimum returns? The shorter the investment horizon, the more the loss can be. For a 1 year investment, the loss can be as high as -47% - meaning that your investment can be reduced to almost half in just a year! But for 10 & 15 years, either the loss is negligible, or there is no loss at all! Probability of Loss: As the investment time horizon increases, the probability of loss also decreases. For a 1 year investment, the possibility of incurring a loss is 36% (a loss occurred 36% of times in our analysis), whereas the possibility of making a loss on a 10 or 15 year investment is 1% and 0% respectively. Returns and Inflation: Even the minimum return from a 15 year investment is 7.23%. This is higher than the average inflation we have seen in India. Thus, if you invest for the long term, even the worst possible return would be inflation beating! (Download this spreadsheet that contains the full data and analysis. You need to be logged-in to download the spreadsheet. Please take advantage of the free registration that takes less than a minute. To know the benefits of registration, please click here.) A Point to Ponder Please note that this analysis has been done in October 2008 - when the stock markets are 46% down from their peak levels seen in January 2008. Also, the period covered in the analysis covers many stock market booms and busts - it covers the Harshad Mehta period, the Ketan Parekh period, the dot com bust, etc. Even then, we see that over the long term, stocks have given a consistent and predictable return. One conclusion that can be derived is that if you are investing for a long to very long term, the level at which you start your investment becomes insignificant. Therefore, do not try to time the market. Lessons I think the conclusion is fairly obvious - Investments in equities give the best, inflation-beating return when you invest in stocks for a long to very long term. And, when you invest for a long to very long term, equity investment is virtually risk free. The primary reason for good returns is that by keeping invested for a long term, you ride the growth of companies. And not to forget the fact that you end up paying far less brokerage! (Please read "Stocks - The winning bet for the long term" to understand long term equity investments better). When to Invest in Stocks Since equities give the best returns in the long run, you should invest in equities only for long term goals. (Please read "Goal Based Investing" to get a step-by-step understand of investing based on goals). Such long term goals could be: * Your retirement * Your child's higher education (if you start investing when the child is very young) * Your child's wedding (again, if you start investing when the child is very young) * Purchase of a house at the time of retirement When Not to Invest in Stocks Since short term returns from equity investment are unpredictable (that is, since stocks are risky for short term investment), you shouldn't invest in stocks if you want to park your funds for a short term. You might be tempted to make a quick buck in market "boom" times, but it is best to resist such temptations! Thus, don't invest in stocks for: * Funding a car purchase that's 2 years away * Funding a vacation that you want to take in a couple of months Conclusion To reiterate our findings: * As the time of equity investment increases, the Variation (or the Standard Deviation) in returns decreases * As the holding period of stocks increases, the returns become much more predictable * As the holding period of shares increases, the possible loss (actual amount of loss) decreases * As the investment time horizon increases, the probability of loss (the possibility of you incurring a loss) decreases * Don't try to time the market - any time is right to start a long term investment * The return from a long term investment is higher than the average inflation - equity investment is inflation beating Investments in equities give the best, inflation-beating return when you invest in stocks for a long to very long term. When you invest for a long to very long term, equity investment is virtually risk free. Happy long-term investing! Other articles you might be interested in: * Income Tax (IT) treatment of House Rent Allowance (HRA) * Only paid out arrears to be subject to TDS for government employees * An introduction to Technical Analysis * Retirement money: How to invest, where to invest * Do you have an SIP? Don't stop it! * Indian banks hike FCNR, NRE deposit rates * Renting vs Buying: To buy a house or rent it? * RBI proposes drastic reduction in clearing charges for outstation cheques * Definition of Residential Statuses: Resident, RNOR, NRI, PIO * An Introduction to Islamic or Shariah Compliant Banking * Early retirement - Why a fixed deposit (FD) is not a good choice * Permanent Account Number (PAN) for an NRI and a PIO -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Do you have a financial plan? Check out my comprehensive Financial Planning Service - I would do a complete analysis of your personal finance, and help you achieve all your financial goals. Click here for more details. My Financial Plan - Financial Planning in India You can have a look at all my products at the Personal Finance Products and Services Store. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- * delicious Bookmark on Delicious * digg Digg this post * facebook Recommend on Facebook * linkedin Share on Linkedin * reddit share via Reddit * stumble Share with Stumblers * twitter Tweet about it * bookmark Bookmark in Browser * email Tell a friend IFrame IFrame Related Articles: * No Related Articles. Filed Under: Uncategorized . Comments 1. Neerav Mehta says: October 29, 2008 at 2:33 pm Nice article, thank you very much for the data analysis, it is very helpful. Assuming that I am Mr. Very Long Term, then what if I temporarily park my funds as Short Term in stock A. Two possibility happens at end of one year (a) if the return is less than 16.04%, then I keep my funds parked there (now as Medium Term) (b) if the return is more than 16.04% then I book profits and reinvest the money in another stock B that had negative return in last year (to compound my profits and assuming that in very Long Term that negative stock would eventually make profit as per this article). I believe this way an investor for Very Long Term can increase their profits. Do you see a downside to this approach or does it make sense? Reply 2. Anonymous says: October 29, 2008 at 10:15 pm Hi Neerav, I am glad you found the analysis beneficial. We can definitely think of variations of the strategy - I have presented a simple picture so that the concept is understood. One thing I would like to point out is that here, I am not talking about investing just in individual stocks. When making investment in stocks for the long term, it would be better to invest in a well-performing mutual fund, so that you get benefits of diversification. If you can do fundamental analysis yourself, you can also invest in a basket of good stocks, say 5-10 stocks. Investing in a single stock would be quite risky. So, in that case, your strategy of selling one stock and investing in an underperforming stock would not hold true. Hope this clarifies... Reply 3. Sailesh says: April 24, 2009 at 7:18 am Hi.. I agree that no one should terminate the SIP in turbulent times. Can you please recommend how to take out money invested in SIP and at what time profits should be taken or any specific manner to keep shifting capital away from equities when it has exhibited appreciation... Reply 4. sue says: April 3, 2009 at 8:33 am Dear Sir, Thank you very much for this article. I have printed it out and will refer to it when i need to remind myself that i need to look at profits only after 15years! kind regards Sue Reply 5. Anonymous says: April 24, 2009 at 10:19 am Hi Sailesh, I always recommend investing for specific goals. (Check out "Goal Based Investing" for more on this). Thus, logically, you should withdraw your investments when you reach your goal. However, since the investment in equity is volatile in the short term, when you are nearing your goal, the equity investment should be shifted gradually in more stable avenues (like debt funds / FDs). For this, you can use systematic withdrawal plans (SWP) - again, these would take away the risk of market timing. I would be writing more about SWPs soon... Reply 6. Sailesh Fatehpuria says: April 25, 2009 at 2:43 am Hi... My equity exposure is primarily not any specific goal based but rather because I believe that this is the best investment instrument for long term capital appreciation. I am willing to know whether any higher return can be achieved through SWPs if i am investing in SIPs and how can that be applied? Thanks.. Reply 7. Anonymous says: May 1, 2009 at 2:07 pm Hi Sailesh, You are absolutely right that equities are the best investment for the long term. So, please keep up the investments. However, if you invest based on goals, you would have proper targets to track your performance. That is why I recommend goal based investing. SIPs remove the risk of timing from investments. In the same way, systematic withdrawal plans (SWPs) remove the risk of timing from withdrawals! Just like you can have an SIP with your fund house, you can also have a SWP with the fund house. Please check with your agent / broker. I would write a detailed article on SWPs soon - thanks for suggesting a great topic! Reply 8. Anonymous says: June 29, 2009 at 3:42 pm Hi Franken, Thanks for drawing my attention to this - I have rectified the problem. Reply 9. Anonymous says: June 29, 2009 at 1:26 am hi thanks for the article could you please upload the spreadsheet. the file is missing. it would be very much appreciated thanks once again Reply 10. bv says: June 4, 2010 at 6:37 pm n b Reply 11. Neeraj says: June 4, 2010 at 6:43 pm Dear Raag, Really nice article and appreciate your efforts in vanishing common man delimmas regarding financial planning. Could you please ans my following queries: 1. How much is the entry and exit load in open ended and close ended equity funds. 2. Could you please suggest few well-performing open ended and close ended equity/mutual funds. Regards, Neeraj Reply 12. Anand says: October 6, 2010 at 4:39 pm The analysis in interesting. The primary point here is that all of them are selling their holding at pre-determined times, else the profits would vanish! NIFTY has 20 year data available. I did a similar study on US DJIA and found that Dow has returned 5.5% CAGR since 1896. Indian markets would return similarly over the next 50 - 80 years. Equity market returns can be assured ONLY when you take profits out of the table. Disclosure: I love Equities than Debt, so this is not an anti-equity propaganda! Since personally I have quadrupled my holdings in 9 years (2001), even post the 2008 slump, I am now of the opinion that taking profits at predefined points is the most important point in generating wealth Reply Speak Your Mind Cancel reply _______________________________ Name * _______________________________ Email * _______________________________ Website ______________________________________________ ______________________________________________ ______________________________________________ ______________________________________________ ______________________________________________ ______________________________________________ ______________________________________________ ______________________________________________ [ Post Comment ] Note: Please post only original questions. Questions that have been answered in the article or as a reply to a previous comment would not be answered again. [ ] Also subscribe to our newsletter, and get the free "Basics of Personal Finance" email course Raag Vamdatt Featured In Get A Free E-Course Join our free newsletter and get Basics of Personal Finance email course completely free! (More Information) Loading What Readers Have To Say I have just started my work and am a novice to all the tax fundas. But you've really cleared things for me. - Arjun Personal Finance Topics Tools PF Gold ULIP PPF NRI PIO Fixed Deposit ITR Retirement SIP Product Review Interest Rate Post Office Loan Insurance Tips MF Stocks Income Tax Investment Basics Products And Services +---------------------------------+ |My Financial Plan - Financial | |Planning Service | |---------------------------------| |Mutual Fund (MF) Portfolio | |Analysis Service | |---------------------------------| |ULIP Evaluation - Review of Your | |Existing ULIP | |---------------------------------| |ULIP Evaluation - Review Before a| |New ULIP Purchase | |---------------------------------| |E-Book: Personal Finance for the | |Young Professional | +---------------------------------+ Current Poll When did you file your income tax return? * [ ] June * [ ] July * [ ] August or later [ Vote ] View Results Loading ... Loading ... -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ********* ********************* ********* ********* ****** *************** ********************* "************ ****************** - ************ ************, ************ ************************" ********************* ****************** ****** ************ ****** *************************** *************** ********************* -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Looking for a financial planner in India? Check out the "My Financial Plan" service. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Facebook IFrame Recent Comments * anup acharya on Public Provident Fund (PPF) - Plan Your Retirement and Save Tax * Harssh Securities | Your Savings. Our Expertise on What is a Systematic Transfer Plan (STP) in MFs and how it can help you * PreetiG on Budget 2010-2011: Service Tax on Property / House / Apartments / Flats * Rakesh Kumar on Income Tax (IT) Benefits of a Home Loan / Housing Loan / Mortgage * CA Karan Batra on NSE Introduces S&P and Dow Jones Derivatives - Should You Invest? * Mits on How to save / avoid Long Term Capital Gain (LTCG) Tax on Sale of a House * saumya on Long Term and Short Term Capital Gain - Income Tax Calculation * yogesh patil on Budget 2010-2011: Service Tax on Property / House / Apartments / Flats * Narendra on Long Term and Short Term Capital Gain - Income Tax Calculation * MANISH KUMAR on How to fill Income Tax Return Form 1 (ITR1) - Instructions and Video Tutorial You May Also Be Interested In SEO Optimization Tips for Blogs - Search Engine Optimization (SEO) for Blogs Best information on cruise deals and late cruise deals to save you money. Loads of cruising tips, tricks, guidance, reviews and help for selecting a cruise line, cruise ship, cruise itinerary and cabin, room or suite. New York City NYC What To Do List. Things to do in New York City for travelers - Tours, Attractions, Activities, Shopping, Dining and more. Your resource for reviews & the best deals on Digital Cameras, Digital SLRs, Camcorders & Video Cameras (High and Standard Definition - HD & SD), Accessories and Photography Books. Answering all your How to blog and WordPress how to questions - WordPress (WP) How To Blog Main Menu * Financial Planning Service * Personal Finance Products & Services * Hindi Edition * Why Register? * About the Author * Contact Us * Financial Planning Home * Must-Read Articles * Reader Testimonials * Glossary of Terms * Polls * Media * Advertise * Partnership Login Username: _____________________ Password: _____________________ [ ] Remember me [ Login >> ] * Register * Lost your password? Article Categories * Financial Planning & Investment * Income Tax * Non Resident Indians * Insurance * Loans * Mutual Funds * News * Other * Real Estate * Shares / Equities Popular Articles * Long Term and Short Term Capital Gain - Income Tax Calculation * Saving Income Tax - Understanding Section 80C Deductions * Provident Fund (PF) and Voluntary Provident Fund (VPF) * Income Tax (IT) Benefits of a Home Loan / Housing Loan / Mortgage * Budget 2010-2011: Service Tax on Property / House / Apartments / Flats * Cost To Company or CTC salary: Understanding and Calculation * Your Provident Fund (PF) account balance now available online * Long Term Capital Gains (LTCG) on Sale of a House - Calculation and Income Tax * Public Provident Fund (PPF) - Plan Your Retirement and Save Tax * Missed the income tax return (ITR) filing deadline of 31st July? Recent Articles * JagoInvestor presents "Action Month" * NSE Introduces S&P and Dow Jones Derivatives - Should You Invest? * Presenting The New And Improved RaagVamdatt.com * Interest rates are increasing - Should you open fixed deposits now to lock into higher rates? * 15 Income Tax resources to help you prepare & file your income tax return (ITR) * Download Latest Income Tax Return (ITR) Forms for FY 2010-11 AY 2011-12 * Income Tax Return (ITR) filing is round the corner - Get a 20% discount now! * Your Provident Fund (PF) account balance now available online * RaagVamdatt.com in media - Articles in Sakaal and mention in Right Choice magazine * Are Mutual Fund (MF) entry loads coming back? Most Shared Articles * Budget 2010-2011: Service Tax on Property / House / Apartments / Flats Google +1 logo1 Twitter logo0 Facebook logo2 * Income Tax (IT) benefit of an education / study loan - Section 80E Google +1 logo0 Twitter logo0 Facebook logo3 * JagoInvestor presents "Action Month" Google +1 logo0 Twitter logo2 Facebook logo0 * 15 Income Tax resources to help you prepare & file your income tax return (ITR) Google +1 logo0 Twitter logo0 Facebook logo2 * Close Ended vs Open Ended Mutual Funds (MFs) Google +1 logo0 Twitter logo0 Facebook logo2 * Non-Resident External (NRE) & Non-Resident Ordinary (NRO) Accounts for NRIs Google +1 logo1 Twitter logo0 Facebook logo1 * Presenting The New And Improved RaagVamdatt.com Google +1 logo0 Twitter logo1 Facebook logo0 * Your Provident Fund (PF) account balance now available online Google +1 logo0 Twitter logo0 Facebook logo1 * 5 things to do as soon as you get a job to secure a healthy financial future Google +1 logo0 Twitter logo0 Facebook logo1 * Reached Section 80C limit? You can still save more income tax! Google +1 logo0 Twitter logo0 Facebook logo1 Know The Author I am a financial planner catering to Indians worldwide. I am passionate about personal finance and financial planning, and believe in long term investment for achieving your financial goals. No wonder stocks are my favourite! [Read More ...] Personal Finance Topics Credit Card Credit Score Derivatives Fixed Deposit Gold Income Tax Insurance Interest Rate Investment Basics ITR Loan MF NRI PIO PF Post Office PPF Product Review Retirement SIP Stocks Tips Tools ULIP Article Archives [___________________] Disclaimer Although the contents of the website are accurate to the best of my knowledge, users are advised to verify them independently before making investment decisions. All logos and trademarks in this site are property of their respective owners. The comments and forum posts are property of their posters. Content directly linked to is property of respective websites. All other content (c) 2007-2011 www.RaagVamdatt.com - All Rights Reserved Return to top of page Copyright (c) 2011 . Nomadic Theme on Genesis Framework . WordPress . Log in * Become my Facebook fan Become my Facebook fan * Connect with me Connect with me * RSS RSS * Tweet with me Tweet with me * Subscribe to my YouTube Channel Subscribe to my YouTube Channel